A Quick Guide to Dividend Taxation

As a masochist – and someone who believes in knowing exactly how bad things can get – I do my own taxes every year.

Since I’m in the process of getting all of my 2017 paperwork together right now, and you might be as well, I thought this is a good time to go over the way different types of dividends get treated.

Obviously, there’s no way I can cover the entire subject in one short article. And this column is no substitute for professional advice from someone who understands your particular situation.

But we can at least go over some of the basics.

Let’s start with common stock dividends, the ones you’re most likely to receive.

Through 2012, “qualified dividends” — the ones you typically get from owning regular common stocks — were taxed at very favorable rates for everyone. And that continues to be true for MOST people.

If you’re in one of the bottom two tax brackets, you won’t owe any taxes on qualified dividends at all. Most people in higher brackets owe 15%.

The exception? For 2017, anyone who made more than $418,400 a year or $470,700 if married.

Folks in that range will pay an extra five percentage points more. That takes them all the way up to a 20% tax rate on qualified dividends.

When you look on your 1040 form you will see a box on line 9b where you enter your qualified dividends. Also, 1099 statements from your broker should specifically note what dividends count as qualified distributions.

From there, you might have to use the IRS’s supplied worksheet to figure out exactly how much tax is owed on those dividends.

Again, for most investors it’ll still be 15%, which is probably lower than your ordinary income rate.

Note, however, that you must have held the stock for more than 60 of the 121 days surrounding the “ex-dividend” date. In addition, you cannot treat qualified dividend payments as “investment income” for investment interest expense deductions. You can forgo the special tax rate and then use them to offset the interest expense.

And if you do your investing in a tax-sheltered account like a traditional IRA or 401(k) plan, there’s some good news: Your dividends are not subject to income taxes right now. However, they will probably be treated as ordinary income when you do start making withdrawals.

Other special types of dividend payments are treated differently …

Three examples of common dividend-paying investments that do NOT get favorable treatment.

Example #1:
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)

REIT dividends are treated as ordinary income. That’s because these companies generally do not pay taxes at the corporate level. Instead, they dole out most of their income to their investors in the form of dividends.

This is why their yields are often higher than other investments. It’s also why Uncle Sam wants as much of those dividend payments as possible.

Example #2:
Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs)

An MLP’s income is treated as if it is earned by “the partners” (i.e., shareholders) and is allocated to them based on their individual stake. The partners also share in any other events that typically affect taxable income, such as deductions and credits.

By all appearances, these payments look like plain dividends.

However, there’s an important difference at tax time. The bulk of the quarterly distributions are considered a return of capital … and not taxable investment income.

Translation: Most of your distributions are tax-deferred! At the same time, parts of your payments can be considered unearned business income. Which is why MLPs are typically best held outside tax shelters like IRA accounts.

Example #3:
Trust Preferred Shares

Only some preferred stock dividends qualify for the 15% dividend tax rate. These are known as “traditional preferred” stocks.

In contrast, any income from “trust preferred” shares will be taxed at your ordinary income rate. That is because they are technically considered debt securities.

It is worth noting that the new tax laws do have some favorable implications for some of the dividends that come from REITs and MLPs for 2018, but we’ll save that for another day.

Meanwhile, if you invest in mutual funds, you probably see various “dividend” payments … even when your fund doesn’t invest in dividend stocks!

Many institutions use the term to denote all kinds of payments, including regular interest.

But the same basic rules apply to your mutual fund holdings …

  • Dividends from common stocks will usually get taxed at the qualified rate,
  • Most other dividends will be treated as ordinary income, and
  • Long-term capital gains will be treated as such.

The tax statements sent from your fund company or brokerage should break the categories up for you.

One last note for anyone reinvesting their dividends …

If you’re taking your payments and putting them back into more shares, that’s terrific!

However, Uncle Sam isn’t going to make your life any easier.

The IRS doesn’t allow you to just figure out an average cost basis for all the shares you’ve bought over time. Instead, you must determine the actual price paid for each purchase.

This makes saving your account statements VERY important!

Having that paper trail will make determining your cost basis much easier. And the longer you practice dividend reinvestment, the more complicated things will become without adequate records.

To a richer life,

Nilus Mattive

Nilus Mattive,
Editor The Rich Life Roadmap

You May Also Be Interested In:

The Fed’s Worst Nightmare

One of the greatest losses to Americans has been the loss of the value of their money. That is why it is important to pay attention to inflation, interest rates, the price of gold, and government debt. It’s why I’m hanging on to my gold, silver, and Bitcoin.

Nilus Mattive

Nilus is the editor for the daily e-letter The Rich Life Roadmap and a Paradigm Press analyst.

Nilus began his professional career at Jono Steinberg’s Individual Investor Group, where he published his original research through a regular investment column. Later, he worked for a private equity business and spent five years editing Standard and Poor’s...

View More By Nilus Mattive