Print the page
Increase font size

Posted February 07, 2022

Sean Ring

By Sean Ring

Russia-China Gas Deal is Latest Bullet US Fires Into Its Foot

  • Russia will supply China with natural gas from its Far East region.
  • Payment for the gas will be settled in euros, not dollars.
  • In effect, China aids Russia to get around US sanctions, which have proven useless anyway.

Good morning to you on this fine Tuesday!

What Now?

Ive written to you before about how I think our Russia policy is crazy.

Ive also shown you what happens when the West sanctions Moscow.

The consequences are plain to see from a sanctions point-of-view.

The geopolitical and macro factors take longer to develop. Until they do.

Suddenly, the fruition of idiocy fully manifests itself.

Joke Biden and his junior varsity foreign policy team continue to plunge the country into macroeconomic chaos.

The evidence is on display - and incontrovertible.

There is no Office of Unintended Consequences in the United States.

But I guarantee you any policy that puts the exorbitant privilege of the US dollar as the worlds reserve currency at risk is unintended.

So Russia and Chinas latest move is the economic equivalent of a kick in the goolies.

On Friday, the Reuters headline read:

Russia, China agree 30-year gas deal via new pipeline, to settle in euros

From the USs perspective, the headline before the comma is bad enough.

But after the comma, its a disaster.

To be sure, this deal makes all the sense in the world for both China and Russia.

China needs energy resources.

Russia needs to diversify its client base away from sanctioning countries.

And both of them want to deal in a currency other than USD.

But for the United States and pretty much the entirety of Europe, its a disaster.

Let me explain.

How does this affect the Ukraine situation?

The tangled mess in Ukraine originated lifetimes ago.

Ukrainians are a people separate and independent of Russia.

Russians believe that they and Ukrainians are one people.

No deal hastily put together in the West will ever change these points of view.

We have to deal with the reality on the ground.

When the Cold War ended, America bragged about winning it and that the Soviet Union lost it.

Russians - especially Vladimir Putin - have never forgiven this offense. Nor have they forgiven the Harvard Boys plundering their country.

Whats worse for Russia is how the US rescinded its promises not to move NATOs borders up against Russias.

Credit: Al-Jazeera

To Russia, the Baltics were bad enough. But Ukraine thats just not happening.

Parking missiles in Ukraine represent a considerable risk to the Russian state.

Caspian Report on YouTube covers this well.

But in a nutshell, Russia doesnt want weapons on its doorstep.

Cuban Missile Crisis, anyone?

Does this have anything to do with Nordstream 2?

Yes.

Quickly, Nordstream 2 is another pipeline recently built but not yet operational thanks to German foot-dragging and American pressure, bringing Russian natural gas to Europe.

Credit: Al-Jazeera

Let me quote former President Trump again from an earlier edition of the Rude:

I think its very sad when Germany makes a massive oil and gas deal with Russia, where youre supposed to be guarding against Russia?,? and Germany goes out and pays billions and billions of dollars a year to Russia, Trump ?told Stoltenberg. So were protecting Germany, were protecting France, were protecting all of these countries. And then numerous of the countries go out and make a pipeline deal with Russia where theyre paying billions of dollars into the coffers of Russia. And I think thats very inappropriate.

So the problems are these, from Americas perspective:

    1. Russia makes money supplying natural gas directly to Germany.
    2. Germany doesnt buy natural gas from America, depriving it of funds.
    3. America pays for NATO to defend Europe, while Europe funds its supposed enemies.
    4. Ukraine loses out on transit fees, strengthening Russias economic hold over it.
    5. America has more difficulty inviting Ukraine into NATO and planting missiles there.

Lets go from first principles: change NATOs mission from bugging Russia to irritating China instead.

Most of these problems go away, at least for America.

What Americas policy has done is drive Russia further into Chinas orbit, and thats just plain dumb.

And Joke Biden has consigned the Germans to a frigid winter indeed if they cant get their energy supplies to warm the place up.

The Germans, as usual, kowtowed to the American president and his directives.

I think Chancellor Scholzs reign will be short if he doesnt depart from his ludicrous stance.

Why does euro settlement matter?

Anytime a country decides against using the US dollar in favor of another currency, US dollar hegemony erodes.

That China and Russia will be using euros to settle this deal isnt a trivial footnote.

Two economic and military powers are deliberately moving away from the dollar.

Really not good, from Americas perspective.

And if the American government sanctions Russia for an actual invasion of Ukraine, Russia will have to accept payments in euros anyway.

My colleague Jim Rickards had this to say in the 5 Min. Forecast:

Russia would have to price its oil and natural gas in euros so that it could receive payment.

Sanctions will include bans of Russian banks from U.S. dollar payment systems and a prohibition on Russian companies seeking finance in Western capital markets.

Additional sanctions will include freezes on financial transactions by Russian leaders and firms, prohibitions of certain high-tech exports to Russia, a ban on Russian investment in U.S. businesses, and perhaps tariffs on U.S. imports of Russian goods.

The U.S. will not prevent Russian bank transactions on SWIFT, the international financial communications network based in Belgium. That would be regarded as an act of war by Russia and would not be supported by European members of SWIFT.

But Jim also agrees with what I wrote about the uselessness of sanctions against Russia anyway:

These sanctions would have some impact on Russia but would not change Russian behavior.

Sanctions have been imposed on Russia since the 2014 annexation of Crimea and have had no material impact on Russian policy. Russia has moved over 20% of its reserves into physical gold bullion stored in Moscow in anticipation of freezes on digital payments.

Because the gold is physical, not digital, it cannot be hacked, frozen, or seized. This gold bullion is worth about $140 billion at current market prices.

Importantly, U.S. sanctions would not affect exports of Russian oil or natural gas.

Russia provides about 10% of all the oil produced in the world. Russia, Saudi Arabia, and the United States combined produce over 33% of all the oil in the world.

Its simply impossible to sanction Russian oil sales. Any interference in Russian oil sales would cause global hyperinflation and global economic collapse at the same time.

The impact on Russia would be marginal; it has a waiting list of customers for the natural gas in China. The impact on Western Europe, especially Germany, would be devastating.

In a best case, higher energy prices from Russian dominance of the Western European market would feed inflation and damage the profitability of manufacturers around the world.

Financial sanctions would reduce global liquidity, increase market uncertainty and possibly trigger a global financial panic of the kinds seen in 2020 and 2008.

If this policy is stupid for America, its positively self-harmful for Germany.

Wrap Up

Americas policy towards Russia is idiotic.

Of course, when politicians make mistakes, even if they realize their mistakes, they cant back down for fear of losing face.

(See: policy, COVID)

America is sowing the seeds of its own economic destruction, and Germany wouldnt escape this situation unscathed.

Its essential to be aware of these manifestations of our central thesis of dollar destruction.

Its a policy so suicidal only academics, politicians, and news anchors can support it.

Until tomorrow.

All the best,

Sean

P.S. If you want to get some great insights into what Ive been writing about with the dollar, you should listen to my friend and colleague Addison Wiggins interview with entrepreneur and investor Mark Moss. Im reading the transcript now, and its chockful of golden nuggets. Check this out from Mark:

And so what we're doing is most people are just looking at financial cycles, and they're going, Well, we're at the end of a long term credit cycle. Interest rates are at zero. What's going to happen next? Is the dollar going to remain the reserve currency? but they're only looking at this one piece right here. And I think you need to understand the other two pieces to understand, like I said, how we got here, what the heck is going on, and most importantly, where we go from here.

King: What Rising Gold Means to You

King: What Rising Gold Means to You

Posted April 24, 2024

By Byron King

The MSM jumped on the bandwagon. The 2024 Gold Rush has begun.
The Kickboxing Economist

The Kickboxing Economist

Posted April 23, 2024

By Sean Ring

If you care about your...country, read Ludwig von Mises and the six lessons of the Austrian Economic School.
The Price of Empire

The Price of Empire

Posted April 22, 2024

By Sean Ring

Mike Johnson’s package passed; now Americans are on the hook for another $95 billion.
The Origin Story

The Origin Story

Posted April 18, 2024

By Sean Ring

Far from an organized plan, my renunciation was a shock to even me.
Yet Another Sanctions Backfire

Yet Another Sanctions Backfire

Posted April 18, 2024

By Sean Ring

Russia keeps building in the face of failing Western sanctions
It’s Higher For Longer

It’s Higher For Longer

Posted April 17, 2024

By Sean Ring

Powell slams the door on premature rate cuts.